# The Engineering Manager's role is under attack \(again\)

- HackerByte page: <https://hackerbyte.net/en/stories/a-discussion-about-the-current-challenges-and-criticisms-faced-by-the-role-of-en-50597014>
- Original source: <https://www.manager.dev/newsletter/the-engineering-manager-s-role-is-under-attack-again>
- Hacker News discussion: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50597014>
- Submitted to Hacker News: 2026-11-22T07:01:00.000Z

A discussion about the current challenges and criticisms faced by the role of engineering management.

## AI-generated summary

The article discusses the recurring trend of tech companies laying off engineering managers and flattening organizational structures, often driven by the perceived efficiency gains from AI. It argues that this approach leads to organizational and relational debt, ultimately harming team performance and psychological safety. The piece offers advice for Engineering Managers \(EMs\) to counter this by articulating the value they provide in tangible terms tied to business goals.

## Key points

- Tech companies are repeatedly laying off engineering managers and flattening hierarchies, citing AI and efficiency.
- This trend erodes relational debt, leading to toxic behavior, conflicts, and reduced collaboration.
- Historical attempts at extreme flattening, like Google's in 2002, have failed, demonstrating the essential role of managers.
- AI's perceived ability to replace human work is accelerating the attack on the EM role.
- EMs can combat this by documenting team problems and framing them as obstacles to larger business goals.
